| Title |
Assessing the Conservation Value of Relocated National Heritage Buildings Through Cultural Heritage Committee |
| DOI |
https://doi.org/10.5659/JAIK.2025.41.8.277 |
| Keywords |
Relocation; Architectural Heritage; National Heritage; Conservation Value; Cultural Heritage Committee |
| Abstract |
The relocation of architectural heritage remains a contentious issue in cultural heritage conservation, as it often raises concerns about the loss
of authenticity and historical context. This study investigates how the conservation value of relocated heritage has been assessed in practice,
with a focus on cases in South Korea. Three relocated historic buildings were examined through an analysis of official deliberation records
from the national Cultural Heritage Committee, using a nine-criteria evaluation framework based on the Hoi An Declaration. Findings show
that assessments of relocated heritage tend to prioritize physical conservation and intangible cultural significance, while factors related to the
authenticity of the new location receive limited attention. The fact that it was relocated has always had a negative impact on its conservation
value. These results highlight the need to more fully integrate location-based authenticity into heritage evaluations. The study offers policy
insights to support more balanced and comprehensive assessment practices for relocated architectural heritage. |