SimSanghoon1
JeonLaurence1
-
(Chungbuk National University, Chungcheongbuk-do 28644, Korea )
Copyright © The Institute of Electronics and Information Engineers(IEIE)
Index Terms
5G, Ka-band, 28 GHz, GaAs, power amplifier, power detector, QFN package
I. INTRODUCTION
5 G FR2 utilizes mm-Wave bands to provide very high data-rate by extending the bandwidth.
However, in a given antenna gain, the use of mm-wave bands leads to smaller effective
area of antenna compared to that of sub-6 GHz frequency range, and results in reduced
sensitivity or interpreted as increased path loss [1-3].
To overcome the small effective area of mm-wave antennas, phased array beamforming
technology is adopted. The antenna space is typically designed around 0.5${\lambda}$
to obviate grating lobe, which corresponds to around 5 mm in 28 GHz. This means all
the components should be mounted within 5 mm ${\times}$ 5 mm area assuming panel arrays.
This size constraint leads to the requirement of components integration into a small
chip area including additional functionality [4,5].
To exploit the 5G FR2, accurate output power control is required, and a power detector
is one of the essential building blocks. Power detectors have been widely used in
modern wireless communication systems and one of the main functional building blocks
on the phased array TX path to detect and control the output power [6-8]. General features of the power detector are sensing the output power and converting
the power levels to corresponding DC voltages. To obviate the size constraint, a power
detector integrated on the PA is highly desirable.
Recently, there have been several reports on Ka-band PA with on chip power detector
in CMOS technology [9-11]. But, the output power is limited due to the power limitation of CMOS technology.
On the other hand, GaAs technologies have been widely used for the high-performance
PA development in mm-Wave [12-20]. However, for Ka-band applications, it is hard to find papers on GaAs PA with on-chip
power detector.
In this paper, a Ka-band power amplifier with on-chip power detector for 5G FR2 application
is presented in a 0.15~${\mu}$m GaAs pHEMT technology. To evaluate the performance
in surface mount use, the PA die chip is attached on a commercial open cavity QFN
package, and the performances are evaluated including the package effects.
II. CIRCUIT DESIGN
Fig. 1 shows simplified schematic of the Ka-band PA in this work. The PA is designed as
three stage cascades to enhance the power gain. Transmission lines and MIM capacitors
are used for matching and bias circuits. The output stage, power stage, is composed
of two Q$_{3}$ transistors.
TL$_{2}$ add up the currents from two Q$_{3}$ drains and combine the output power.
The output matching is carried out mainly as two-sections with TL$_{2}$-C$_{1}$ and
TL$_{3}$-C$_{2}$. To achieve more than 27 dBm output power, the size of each transistor
Q$_{3}$ was selected as 8-finger 80-${\mu}$m to have more than 25 dBm output power.
This leads to more than 27 dBm output power by adding up the powers from two Q$_{3}$
transistors considering insertion losses of the output matching network. The optimum
impedance of each Q$_{3}$ is found as around 9.5-2.3j Ohm by load-pull simulation.
The two-section matching network transforms 50 Ohm to the optimum impedance. DC power
is supplied to Q$_{3}$ by TL$_{4}$ through TL$_{2}$ and TL$_{3}$. To drive the power
stage, the PA input signal is amplified by gain stage composed of Q$_{1}$ (4-finger
70-${\mu}$m) and distributed into two paths by TL$_{1}$ to feed the gate of Q$_{2}$(4-finger
40-${\mu}$m), driver stage. Again, the drive signals from Q$_{2}$ drains are fed into
the gate of Q$_{3}$, power stage. The input, driver, and power stages are biased with
current 40 mA, 60 mA, and 160 mA respectively. Interstage matching between stages
are carried out as conjugate gain matching.
The on-chip power detector is designed using the directional coupler CL to sample
incident wave from PA to antenna. Fig. 2 shows the operation principle of the power detector with the directional coupler.
Incident wave V$_{+}$ is coupled to coupling port P$_{3}$ with the coupling coefficient
${\alpha}$ which is lower than unity, and the coupled wave can be represented as ${\alpha}$V$_{+}$.
The reflected wave V$_{-}$ from the load is coupled to isolation port P$_{4}$, and
the coupled wave can be represented as ${\alpha}$V$_{\mathrm{-.}}$ The coupled wave
${\alpha}$V$_{+}$ is rectified by the rectifier composed of diode, capacitor, and
resistor, which is a conventional envelope detector. The size of the diode is 1-finger
1-${\mu}$m. The output V$_{\mathrm{pd}}$ of the rectifier is a DC voltage proportional
to the swing voltage of the coupled wave ${\alpha}$V$_{+}$ ,and can be used for the
power detection. A termination resistor R$_{\mathrm{T}}$ in series with bypass capacitor
is connected to the isolation port P$_{4}$ to absorb ${\alpha}$V$_{-}$ from reflected
wave. The directional coupler samples only the incident wave V$_{+}$, which enables
the detector insensitive to the load impedance variations. To minimize loading effect
by the power detector, a low coupling coefficient ${\alpha}$ is desirable. However,
a low coupling coefficient leads to a reduced sensitivity of the power detector. To
enhance the sensitivity while maintaining low coupling coefficient, the diode in the
rectifier is biased with V$_{\mathrm{bias}}$, 0.9 V. Fig. 3 shows the EM simulation result of the directional coupler. The coupling coefficient
is around -20 dB, and the directivity is around 9 dB at 28 GHz. The insertion loss
is less than -0.08 dB, which also means very close to 50~ohm matching. The low coupling
coefficient and low insertion loss minimizes loading effect of the power detector.
The impact on the detector accuracy with low directivity is accuracy degradation in
an unmatched condition. Higher directivity can be obtained with around quarter wavelength
directional coupler which is around 900 um at 28 GHz. In this work, the main design
goal of the power detector was to reduce the size occupation and loading effect with
reasonable detection accuracy.
Fig. 1. Simplified schematic of the Ka-band power amplifier.
Fig. 2. Operation principle of the power detector.
Fig. 3. Simulation result of the directional coupler.
III. MEASUREMENT RESULTS
The PA was fabricated using WINSEMI 0.15 ${\mu}$m E-mode pHEMT technology. Fig. 4 shows the microphotograph of the fabricated Ka-band PA. The chip size is 2.09 mm
${\times}$ 1.28 mm including pads. The PA die chip is attached on a commercial open
cavity QFN package as in Fig. 5 to evaluate the performance in surface mount use. To enhance the thermal spreading
from the die, a high thermal conductivity epoxy is used for the die attach. The performances
are evaluated including the package effects while mounted on PCB. The die attached
QFN package is sold on PCB, and the performances are measured by probing on PCB. To
incorporate the bonding wire effect at the input port and the output port, an additional
inductance around 0.35 nH was included in design stage assuming two or three bonding
wires in parallel and assuming within 1 mm wire length.
4 V supply is applied to the PA drain while biased total 260 mA quiescent current.
Fig. 6 shows the measured S-parameters. The small signal gain is over 22~dB from 26.6 GHz
to 29.2 GHz. The input return loss is over 6 dB, and the output return loss is over
8 dB in the operation frequency. Comparing to the simulation results, S$_{21}$ is
roughly similar to the measurements. S$_{11}$ and S$_{22}$ are quite deviated from
the simulation, but still within an acceptable range. Fig. 7 shows the measured output power and power added efficiency in the operation frequency.
The output P1dB is over 26.9 dBm, the saturated output power is over 27.4 dBm, and
the maximum PAE is 25~30%. Fig. 8 shows the measured power detector output voltage on V$_{\mathrm{pd}}$ versus the
PA output power. The power detector shows very coherent output voltage to the output
power and the operation frequency. The voltage deviation increases with the output
power, but still has a very good coherency up to the saturated output power. At 27.4
dBm output, the detector output voltage is 1.81~1.95 V from 26.6 GHz to 29.2 GHz.
This corresponds to ${\pm}$ 3.7% variation across the operation frequency, which is
still very coherent values regarding the wide operation frequencies. The deviation
increasing with higher output is mainly due to the harmonic component variations with
frequencies. Table 1 shows comparison with previously reported Ka-band power amplifiers in GaAs pHEMT
technology. This work demonstrated comparable performances with on-chip power detector
and QFN package.
Fig. 5. Packaged PA on an open cavity QFN.
Fig. 6. Measured S-parameters.
Fig. 7. Measured output power and power added efficiency.(* Simulations with other frequencies are very close or in between the simulation results 26.6 GHz and 29.2 GHz)
Fig. 8. Measured power detector output voltage versus output power.(*Simulation results with the frequencies are almost the same and depicted with nominal data)
Table 1. Performance Comparison of Ka band power amplifiers in GaAs pHEMT technology (*~results in this work include losses with QFN package, **~simulation results)
Ref.
|
Freq.
(GHz)
|
P1dB
(dBm)
|
Psat
(dBm)
|
PAE
(%)
|
On chip
Power Detector
|
Chip Area (mm$^{2}$)
/Package
|
[13]
|
30
|
29.5
|
-
|
31
|
no
|
6.5/ bare die
|
[14]
|
28
|
25.5
|
28.5
|
24.5
|
no
|
5.1/ bare die
|
**[16]
|
24~28
|
-
|
31
|
27.3
|
no
|
4.5/ bare die
|
[17]
|
27-30
|
27.2-28.2
|
27.9-28.9
|
26.8-30.8
|
no
|
5/ bare die
|
*This work
|
26.6-29.2
|
>26.9
|
> 27.4
|
25-30
|
yes
|
2.7/ QFN
|
IV. CONCLUSIONS
This paper presents a Ka-band power amplifier with on-chip power detector in a commercial
0.15 ${\mu}$m GaAs pHEMT technology. The chip size is 2.09 mm ${\times}$ 1.28~mm including
on-chip power detector and I/O pads. The die chip is attached on a commercial QFN
package to evaluate the performances in surface mount use. The power detector has
very coherent output voltage across the operation frequency from 26.6 GHz to 29.2
GHz. The saturated output power is over 27.4 dBm, with the PAE$_{\mathrm{max}}$ of
25~30%. The authors expect this work will contribute to performance improvement and
commercialize of mm-wave systems such as 5G FR2 applications.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This research was supported by Chungbuk National University Korea National University
Development Project (2020)
References
Fujii Y., Iye T., Tsuda K., Tanibayashi A., 2021, A 28 GHz Beamforming Technique for
5G Advanced Communication Systems, 2021 23rd International Conference on Advanced
Communication Technology (ICACT), pp. 96-99
Hausl C., Emmert J., Mielke M., Mehlhorn B., Rowell C., 2022, Mobile Network Testing
of 5G NR FR1 and FR2 Networks: Challenges and Solutions, 2022 16th European Conference
on Antennas and Propagation (EuCAP), pp. 1-5
Vikstedt J., 2018, Introduction of 5G Over-the-Air Measurements, 2018 IEEE Asia-Pacific
Conference on Antennas and Propagation (APCAP), pp. 471-475
Shi B., Nasimuddin , Qing X., Chin F., 2021, Wideband Circularly Polarized LTCC Modular
Phased Array Antenna at Ka-band, 2021 IEEE International Symposium on Antennas and
Propagation and USNC-URSI Radio Science Meeting (APS/URSI), pp. 1179-1180
Bao K., Zhou J., Wang L., Sun A., Zhang Q., Shen Y., 2018, A 29–30GHz 64-element Active
Phased array for 5G Application, 2018 IEEE/MTT-S International Microwave Symposium
- IMS, pp. 492-495
Lee S., Song Y., Nam S., 2008, Fast RSSI circuit using novel power detector for wireless
communication, 2008 International SoC Design Conference, pp. I-9-I-12
Katre S., Tirmanwar S., Ghosh D., 2021, Broadband CMOS RF Logarithmic Power Detector
for sub-6 GHz 5G Applications, 2021 25th International Symposium on VLSI Design and
Test (VDAT), pp. 1-4
Qayyum S., Negra R., 2017, 0.16 mW, 7–70 GHz distributed power detector with 75 dB
voltage sensitivity in 130 nm standard CMOS technology, 2017 12th European Microwave
Integrated Circuits Conference (EuMIC), pp. 13-16
Kuo , et al. , 2021, A 5G FR2 (n257/n258/n261) Transmitter Front-End with a Temperature-Invariant
Integrated Power Detector for Closed-Loop EIRP Control, 2021 IEEE Radio Frequency
Integrated Circuits Symposium (RFIC), pp. 175-178
Munzer D., Mannem N. S., Garay E. F., Wang H., May 2022, Single-Ended Quadrature Coupler-Based
VSWR Resilient Joint mm-Wave True Power Detector and Impedance Sensor, in IEEE Transactions
on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 70, No. 5, pp. 2802-2814
Bhagavatula V., et al. , May 2022, A 5G FR2 Power-Amplifier With an Integrated Power-Detector
for Closed-Loop EIRP Control, in IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits, Vol. 57, No.
5, pp. 1257-1266
Navid Hosseinzadeh , AUGUST 2016, Wideband 5 W Ka-Band GaAs Power Amplifier, IEEE
MICROWAVE AND WIRELESS COMPONENTS LETTERS, Vol. 26, No. 8
Cho S. -J., Wang C., Maharjan R. K., Kim N. -Y., 2012, An optimized 0.1 um T-gate
AlGaAs/ InGaAs/GaAs PHEMT power amplifier MMIC for Ka-band applications, 2012 Asia
Pacific Microwave Conference Proceedings, pp. 4-6
Lee H. D., Kong S., Park B., Lee K. C., Park J. -S., Kim J. -G., 2018, A 28-GHz 28.5-dBm
power amplifier using 0.15-µm InGaAs E-mode pHEMT technology, 2018 International SoC
Design Conference (ISOCC), pp. 257-258
Nguyen D. P., Pham B. L., Pham A. -V., A compact 29% PAE at 6 dB power back-off E-mode
GaAs pHEMT MMIC Doherty power amplifier at Ka-band, 2017 IEEE MTT-S International
Microwave Symposium (IMS), pp. 1683-1686
Wang K., Yan Y., Liang X., 2018, A K-band power amplifier in a 0.15-um GaAs pHEMT
process, 2018 IEEE MTT-S International Wireless Symposium (IWS), pp. 1-3
Huang I., et al. , 2018, A 29.6 dBm 29-GHz Power Amplifier for Satellite and 5G Communications
Using 0.15-μm GaAs p-HEMT Technology, 2018 Asia-Pacific Microwave Conference (APMC),
pp. 986-988
Nguyen D. P., Pham B. L., Pham A. -V., Jan. 2019, A Compact Ka-Band Integrated Doherty
Amplifier With Reconfigurable Input Network, in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory
and Techniques, Vol. 67, No. 1, pp. 205-215
Nguyen D. P., Tran X. -T., Nguyen N. L. K., Nguyen P. T., Pham A. -V., 2019, A Wideband
High Efficiency Ka-Band MMIC Power Amplifier for 5G Wireless Communications, 2019
IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), pp. 1-5
Martin D. N., Enrico de Falco P., Roberg M., Lasser G., Barton T. W., July 2020, An
18–38-GHz K-/Ka-Band Reconfigurable Chireix Outphasing GaAs MMIC Power Amplifier,
in IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 68, No. 7, pp. 3028-3038
Sanghoon Sim received the B.S., M.S., and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering
from the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST), Daejeon, Korea,
in 2001, 2003, and 2009, respectively. From 2009 to 2010, he was a postdoctoral researcher
with the department of electrical engineering, KAIST, where he was engaged in millimeter-wave
IC design for UWB radar applications. From 2010 to 2018, he was a principal engineer
at RFcore. From 2018 to 2020, he was a principal engineer at Samsung Electronics.
In 2020, he joined the Faculty of Electronics Engineering, Chungbuk National University,
Korea, where he is currently an Assistant Professor. His research interests include
millimeter-wave ICs and phased array systems.
Laurence Jeon received the B.S., M.S., and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering
from the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST), Daejeon, Korea,
in 1991, 1993, and 1998, respectively. From 1998 to 2000, he held position of Engineer
at Material and Device Lab. in LGCIT (LG Corporate Institute of Technology), Seoul,
Korea. During that time he worked in development of various MMIC and hybrid technology
based circuits including millimeter wave power amplifiers, mixers, LNA and switches
operating from L band through W band. His masters’ research concerned the numerical
charge control model of GaAs HEMT and MESFET. This theme continued and extended through
his Ph.D. research regarding the large signal modeling of HEMT and MESFET. He is now
the president of RFcore Co., Ltd Sungnam, Korea, since November 2000.